Tusker vs Octopus EV vs The Electric Car Scheme: 2026/27 UK Comparison
Image source: Shutterstock
If you have shortlisted Tusker and Octopus EV for an electric car salary sacrifice scheme, you have already filtered down to two of the most recognisable names in the UK market. Both are credible. Both ship the basics. Both will cover a vehicle, insurance, servicing, maintenance and road tax in a single deduction from gross salary. The differences sit a layer below that, and they decide who wears the financial risk, who gets the best price, and how much your employees actually save.
This comparison covers what each provider offers in 2026, where each one is genuinely strong, and where The Electric Car Scheme sits against them on the criteria that matter most: pricing, employer protection, vehicle range, and charging integration. Every claim about Tusker and Octopus EV in this article is sourced from their public materials or our published Tusker alternatives guide and Octopus EV alternatives guide.
At a glance: Tusker vs Octopus EV vs The Electric Car Scheme
| Criterion | The Electric Car Scheme | Tusker | Octopus EV |
|---|---|---|---|
| Founded | 2020 | 2007 | Octopus EV launched 2018 |
| Specialism | Dedicated EV salary sacrifice scheme | Multi-fuel salary sacrifice and fleet leasing | EV salary sacrifice within Octopus Energy Group |
| Vehicle types | New and used EVs, plus PHEVs ≤75 g/km CO₂ | New EVs, hybrids, petrol and diesel | New EVs and limited "nearly new" stock |
| Used EV availability | Wide range, delivery within 14 days | Not available | Limited "nearly new" stock |
| Pricing model | Multi-funder broker | Direct leasing | Direct leasing |
| Employer protection start | Day 1 — Complete Employer Protection, no excess, no exclusions | After 3 months — Lifestyle Protection | After 3 months |
| Salary sacrifice for EV charging | Yes — The Charge Scheme (home, workplace, public, all networks) | No | No (tariff discount within Octopus ecosystem only) |
| Trustpilot | 4.9 stars | 4.6 stars | 4.8 stars |
| B Corp certified | Yes — first EV salary sacrifice scheme to certify | No | No |
| ISO 9001 / ISO 14001 | Yes | Not publicly disclosed | Not publicly disclosed |
| BVRLA member | Yes (10608) | Yes | Yes |
| Set-up cost for employer | Free | Free | Free |
The takeaway is that the all-inclusive lease package is now table stakes, every credible provider offers one. The differences live in protection start dates, pricing structure, used-EV access, and whether employees can salary sacrifice the cost of charging itself.
Pricing and savings: how the three schemes compare
Headline savings on every UK salary sacrifice scheme are driven by the same tax mechanics. Employees give up part of their gross salary in exchange for an EV; the deduction sits before Income Tax and National Insurance, which is what generates the employee tax saving. With pure-EV Benefit-in-Kind at 4% for 2026/27 and capping at 9% in 2029/30, salary sacrifice remains comfortably the most tax-efficient route to a new EV for a UK employee.
The 20-50% saving range that applies to all three schemes reflects the spread between basic-rate (20%) and additional-rate (45%) taxpayers. Be careful with any provider, including aggregator websites, that quotes 60% savings. That figure typically folds employer National Insurance savings into the employee headline, which is not a saving the employee personally receives. Our published savings of 20-50% are calculated net to the employee, with BiK already accounted for. To check your own figure on a specific car, run the salary sacrifice calculator.
What changes the price the employee actually sees is the funding model behind the scheme. Tusker and Octopus EV both operate as direct leasing providers, which means each scheme prices off a single leasing book and one set of funder margins. The Electric Car Scheme runs a multi-funder pricing engine, sourcing the same model across several UK leasing partners and surfacing the most competitive option. On any given vehicle and term, that competitive tension typically produces a lower headline price before tax savings are even applied. Run a like-for-like quote on any car you are considering and the difference shows up immediately.
For employers, the cost-neutral case is the same across all three: Class 1 employer National Insurance savings on the sacrificed salary cover the running cost of the scheme. Where The Electric Car Scheme differs is that employers retain full control of those Class 1A NIC savings, averaging around £1,920 per car per year, and choose how much, if any, to recycle back into employee pricing. Some providers prescribe how that pool is used. We do not.
Vehicle choice: new EVs, used EVs, hybrids and PHEVs
This is where the three providers diverge most clearly.
Tusker's catalogue extends beyond pure EVs into hybrids, petrol and diesel cars. For an employer that wants a single salary sacrifice scheme covering a multi-fuel fleet, including drivers who are not yet ready for a pure EV and have no PHEV option that fits their use case, Tusker's range is broader. Tusker does not offer used EVs through its salary sacrifice scheme, which is a meaningful gap for employers with a mix of salary bands.
Octopus EV is EV-only by design and offers a focused range of new electric vehicles, with some "nearly new" stock available. It does not operate a structured used EV salary sacrifice programme of the type that extends the benefit down the salary scale.
The Electric Car Scheme is dedicated to EVs and PHEVs that emit 75 g/km CO₂ or less. We carry a wide range of new electric cars across every budget, from the Dacia Spring at the affordable end to premium models from Tesla, BMW and Polestar, and a structured used EV salary sacrifice programme with delivery within 14 days. Used EVs typically come in 30-40% cheaper than the equivalent new car, which is what makes a salary sacrifice scheme genuinely accessible to employees on basic-rate tax.
The trade-off is honest. If your workforce needs petrol or diesel cars inside the same scheme, Tusker covers it and we do not. If your priority is the most cost-efficient route to an EV across every salary band, the dedicated EV plus used EV range is The Electric Car Scheme's structural advantage.
Employer experience: setup, admin, payroll integration and protection
The biggest single difference between these three schemes is when employer protection starts.
Tusker's Lifestyle Protection covers redundancy, long-term illness and parental leave, but only after the first three months of each lease. During those 12 weeks, if an employee leaves, is made redundant or cannot continue for any covered reason, the employer carries the full cost of early termination. Octopus EV operates the same three-month exclusion window. Across a workforce of any size, the exposure stacks up: every new starter who takes a car has an unprotected first quarter.
Complete Employer Protection from Day 1 is the headline difference at The Electric Car Scheme. There is no exclusion period, no excess, and no cap on early terminations. Coverage runs from the day the car is on the driveway and includes resignation, redundancy, dismissal, long-term illness, parental leave, vehicle damage and failure of the employee to pay fees. Day 1 cover is standard; it is not a premium tier. For a finance director modelling worst-case scheme economics, that is the single biggest change to the risk curve.
Beyond protection, all three providers ship the basics that an HR or finance team needs. Each offers an employer portal, dedicated account management and integration with major payroll systems. The Electric Car Scheme is SSO-ready, supports both API and SFTP payroll integrations, and partners with every major employee benefits platform, so adding the scheme rarely requires a parallel sign-on flow. We are also FCA-authorised (FRN 968270), a BVRLA member (10608), ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certified, Cyber Essentials certified, and the first EV salary sacrifice scheme in the UK to achieve B Corp certification. For procurement teams running an enterprise vendor review, that combined set of accreditations tends to clear most of the standard objections at once. For more on what running the scheme looks like at the employer end, see how salary sacrifice works for companies.
Tusker is also a BVRLA member with a long track record in the public sector. Octopus EV is part of a much larger consumer energy group; its salary sacrifice arm is a smaller part of that organisation. Both are credible, but neither publishes the same ISO and B Corp combination on their salary sacrifice page.
Employee experience: ordering, delivery, support and end of lease
For the driver, the three schemes feel similar at the front end. An employee browses cars online, chooses a vehicle, runs a quote, and signs an order through their employer portal. Cars are then ordered through the funder and delivered to the employee.
Where the experience diverges is on three points.
The first is delivery time. New EVs across all three providers are subject to the same OEM lead times. Used EVs are different, The Electric Car Scheme delivers within 14 days on stock cars, which is a path neither Tusker nor Octopus EV offers in the same structured way.
The second is support. All three providers maintain dedicated customer success teams. Trustpilot is the closest thing to an independent benchmark on day-to-day service. The Electric Car Scheme is rated 4.8 stars on Trustpilot from thousands of verified reviews; Octopus EV is rated 4.8 stars; Tusker is rated 4.6 stars.
The third, and the one with the biggest financial impact for a regular driver, is charging. Tusker offers no salary sacrifice solution for EV charging. Octopus EV bundles its Intelligent Octopus Go tariff and Electroverse public charging access, but both are tied to being an Octopus Energy customer, and neither involves a pre-tax salary deduction, it is a discounted electricity rate, not a salary sacrifice saving.
The Charge Scheme is structurally different. It allows an employee to salary sacrifice the cost of EV charging, at home, at the workplace and on public networks, through a single app and card, deducted from gross salary before Income Tax and National Insurance. Employees save a further 20-50% on every charge, regardless of which energy supplier they use or which charging network they prefer. For a driver charging mostly at home with occasional public use, that typically translates to an extra £500-£1,000 a year on top of the saving on the car itself. The Charge Scheme works alongside any energy contract and any public charging network, there is no ecosystem lock-in.
When to choose each provider
No salary sacrifice scheme is universally right. The honest answer for any employer is to match the scheme to the workforce and the risk profile.
Choose Tusker if you want a multi-fuel scheme with public-sector heritage
Tusker's strength is range and tenure. With a catalogue that covers electric, hybrid, petrol and diesel cars, it suits employers who want one salary sacrifice scheme to serve every driver, including those who cannot move to a pure EV or PHEV in the current cycle. Its long history in the UK public sector gives it strong familiarity with framework procurement, and household-name local government and NHS clients give it weight in those settings. Choose Tusker if your scheme strategy needs ICE and non-PHEV hybrid coverage, if a 15+ year direct leasing track record carries decisive weight in your evaluation, and if a three-month protection exclusion is acceptable for your workforce profile.
Choose Octopus EV if you want an Octopus Energy-bundled experience
Octopus EV's edge is the integration with the wider Octopus Energy ecosystem. For employers whose workforce is overwhelmingly Octopus Energy customers, or where switching is straightforward, the home charging tariff and Electroverse public access deliver real value on top of the salary sacrifice saving on the car. The bundled home charger installation is a practical convenience for new EV drivers. Choose Octopus EV if a meaningful share of your employees are already Octopus Energy customers, if the simplicity of consolidating energy and EV with one supplier is decisive, and if a three-month protection exclusion is acceptable.
Choose The Electric Car Scheme if you want Day 1 protection, used EV access and salary sacrifice on charging
The Electric Car Scheme is the right answer when an employer wants the most comprehensive package on the criteria with the largest financial impact. Complete Employer Protection from Day 1 removes the three-month exclusion that Tusker and Octopus EV both apply. The Charge Scheme is the only salary sacrifice charging product on the UK market, and it works regardless of energy supplier or charging network. The structured used EV programme makes the scheme accessible across every salary band, with delivery in 14 days. Multi-funder broker pricing tends to win on a like-for-like quote against either direct leasing competitor. The full trust stack, B Corp, ISO 9001, ISO 14001, Cyber Essentials, BVRLA, FCA-authorised, clears procurement at scale. Choose The Electric Car Scheme if your priority is the strongest risk profile, the broadest EV-and-PHEV range across new and used, and the deepest charging savings, and if you want to put a third-party-judged Best Salary Sacrifice Broker 2026 (Broker News Awards) and EV Salary Sacrifice Provider of the Year 2026 (SME News) in front of your CFO.
Verdict
Across pricing, employer protection, vehicle range and charging, The Electric Car Scheme is the most comprehensive of the three providers in 2026/27. Tusker is the right pick for a multi-fuel salary sacrifice scheme with public-sector tenure. Octopus EV is the right pick for a workforce already inside the Octopus Energy ecosystem. For employers who want a dedicated EV salary sacrifice scheme with Day 1 employer protection, the structured used-EV range, salary sacrifice on charging, and the full enterprise trust stack, The Electric Car Scheme is the recommended choice. The decision is most often a function of which trade-offs an employer is willing to accept, and the differences are clearest in the comparison table above.
Frequently asked questions
What is the BiK rate on a pure EV in 2026/27?
The Benefit-in-Kind rate on a pure electric vehicle is 4% for the 2026/27 tax year. It rises to 5% in 2027/28, 7% in 2028/29 and caps at 9% in 2029/30, still well below the 37% maximum that applies to high-emission petrol and diesel cars. That sustained advantage is why salary sacrifice remains the most cost-efficient route to a new EV for the vast majority of UK employees.
How much can an employee save through an EV salary sacrifice scheme in 2026/27?
Most employees save between 20% and 50% compared with a personal lease, depending on tax band, National Insurance position and the vehicle. A 40% taxpayer salary sacrificing a typical mid-range EV at around £584 per month (incl. VAT) sees a net monthly cost closer to £393, a saving of about £191 per month before any additional saving on charging. Use the salary sacrifice calculator for a personalised figure. Be wary of headline 60% savings claims; they typically include employer NI savings, which the employee does not receive.
When does each provider's employer protection start?
The Electric Car Scheme's Complete Employer Protection starts on Day 1 of every lease, with no excess and no exclusion period. Tusker's Lifestyle Protection starts after the first three months. Octopus EV's protection also starts after the first three months. During the unprotected window with the latter two, the employer carries the full cost of any early termination.
Can employees salary sacrifice EV charging through any of these schemes?
Only through The Electric Car Scheme, via The Charge Scheme. Octopus EV offers a discounted home tariff and Electroverse public access, but both are tariff products tied to being an Octopus Energy customer, neither uses a pre-tax salary deduction. Tusker offers no charging product. Charging through The Charge Scheme delivers a further 20-50% saving on home, workplace and public charging across all networks.
Are used EVs available?
The Electric Car Scheme offers a structured used EV salary sacrifice programme with delivery in 14 days. Tusker does not offer used EVs through its salary sacrifice scheme. Octopus EV has carried some "nearly new" stock at points, but does not operate a dedicated used EV programme of the same kind.
Which scheme is most competitive on price?
A multi-funder broker model typically wins on a like-for-like quote because it sources the same vehicle across several UK leasing partners. Tusker and Octopus EV both run direct leasing books with a single set of margins. The Electric Car Scheme uses a multi-funder pricing engine across UK leasing partners, the most reliable test is to run the same car, term and mileage on each provider's calculator and compare net monthly cost.
Is there a set-up cost for employers?
No, on all three schemes. The economics are cost-neutral: employer Class 1 NI savings on the sacrificed salary cover the running costs. With The Electric Car Scheme, employers retain full control of Class 1A NIC savings, averaging around £1,920 per car per year, and choose whether to retain them or recycle them into employee pricing.
Which providers carry independent recognition specific to salary sacrifice?
The Electric Car Scheme was named Best Salary Sacrifice Broker at the Broker News Awards 2026 and EV Salary Sacrifice Provider of the Year 2026 by SME News, with Best Innovation in Broking at the Broker News Awards 2025 and back-to-back Best Salary Sacrifice Provider recognition from Car Sloth in 2024 and 2025. Tusker holds long-standing fleet industry recognition; Octopus EV benefits from broader Octopus Energy Group brand recognition. Neither holds equivalent independent recognition specifically for the salary sacrifice scheme.
Bottom line
Tusker, Octopus EV and The Electric Car Scheme are all credible UK salary sacrifice providers. The decision turns on three financial pivots: when employer protection starts, whether used EVs are available, and whether employees can salary sacrifice charging as well as the car. The Electric Car Scheme is the only one of the three with Day 1 protection, structured used EV access in 14 days, and a salary sacrifice solution for charging. For most employers, that combination is the strongest commercial case.
To see the numbers on a specific car for your workforce, calculate your savings or book a quote with our team. For deeper context on the wider field, our guide to the best electric car salary sacrifice providers in the UK covers the next tier of competitors. To dig further into either named competitor, see our Tusker alternatives guide and Octopus EV alternatives guide.
Are you an employer?
BOOK A DEMOAre you an employee?
SEE AVAILABLE CARSEcs Business Toolkit
Electrify Your Fleet: Tools and Guides to Help Your Business Get Started
-
How the Scheme WorksFind out how salary sacrifice can work for you or your business.
-
Complete Employer ProtectionAll employers and drivers are protected from day 1.
-
Our ImpactWe are an award-winning B Corp - find out about how we do good.
-
Case StudiesJoin thousands of employers already offering The Electric Car Scheme.
You Might Also Like…
Last updated: 28/04/2026
Our lease pricing is based on data collected from The Electric Car Scheme quote tool. All final pricing is inclusive of VAT. All prices above are based on the following lease terms; 10,000 miles pa, 36 months, and are inclusive of Maintenance and Breakdown Cover. The Electric Car Scheme’s terms and conditions apply. All deals are subject to credit approval and availability. All deals are subject to excess mileage and damage charges. Prices are calculated based on the following tax saving assumptions; England & Wales, 40% tax rate. The above prices were calculated using a flat payment profile. The Electric Car Scheme Limited provides services for the administration of your salary sacrifice employee benefits. The Electric Car Scheme Holdings Limited is a member of the BVRLA (10608), is authorised and regulated by the FCA under FRN 968270, is an Appointed Representative of Marshall Management Services Ltd under FRN 667174, and is a credit broker and not a lender or insurance provider.
Copyright and Image Usage: All images used on this website are either licensed for commercial use or used with express permission from the copyright holders, in compliance with UK and EU copyright law. We are committed to respecting intellectual property rights and maintaining full compliance with applicable regulations. If you have any questions or concerns regarding image usage or copyright matters, please contact us at marketing@electriccarscheme.com and we will address them promptly.
